A practical guide to semen analysis, IVF, ICSI, sperm retrieval and male fertility surgery for Shia Muslim patients
For Muslim couples experiencing difficulty having a child, infertility can raise both medical and religious questions. You may want to understand why pregnancy has not occurred, while ensuring that any investigations or treatment remain consistent with your Islamic beliefs.
For Shia Muslim men, questions may arise about semen collection, masturbation, fertility examinations, IVF, sperm retrieval and the use of donated sperm or eggs.
The encouraging message is that several established treatments for male infertility may be compatible with Shia Islamic principles, depending on the circumstances and the guidance of your religious authority.
However, Islamic rulings are not identical across all Shia communities or religious scholars. What is permitted may depend on the particular procedure, how it is performed and the religious authority you follow.
This article explains the medical options available, highlights important religious considerations and provides practical guidance for couples seeking fertility care in Australia.
Dr Jack Crozier is a Brisbane-based urologist and fellowship-trained andrologist who assesses and treats male infertility, including azoospermia, reproductive tract obstruction and conditions that may require reproductive microsurgery.
Patients from Brisbane, regional Queensland, interstate Australia and overseas can seek specialist assessment.
Learn more about male infertility assessment and treatment in Brisbane.
Understanding Male Infertility
Male infertility means that a problem involving sperm production, sperm transport, ejaculation or another aspect of male reproductive function is contributing to difficulty achieving pregnancy.
Male factors contribute to approximately half of infertility cases, either alone or alongside female reproductive factors. [1,2]
Common causes include reduced sperm production, poor sperm movement, varicoceles (enlarged veins around the testicle), reproductive tract blockages, hormonal problems, genetic conditions and previous testicular injury or surgery.
Some men have azoospermia, meaning that no sperm are identified in the semen.
Importantly, an abnormal semen analysis does not always mean that natural pregnancy is impossible, and a diagnosis of azoospermia does not necessarily mean that sperm are absent from the testicles.
The first step is to understand the underlying cause before deciding whether treatment is appropriate.
Read more about azoospermia and its causes.
What Does Shia Islam Say About Fertility Treatment?
Many Shia Islamic scholars recognise the importance of marriage, parenthood and seeking appropriate medical treatment.
Within Twelver Shia Islam, religious questions about fertility treatment are commonly considered through the rulings of a marja al-taqlid, a senior religious authority whose jurisprudential guidance a person follows.
This means that there is not one universal ruling covering every fertility procedure for every Shia Muslim.
Published research has identified differences between Shia scholars concerning sperm donation, egg donation, embryo donation and surrogacy. [5,6]
For example, published guidance from Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani permits IVF using a married couple's own sperm and eggs in principle, although the procedures used to obtain and transfer them must also be considered. [7,9]
Published rulings attributed to Grand Ayatollah Ali Khamenei similarly permit IVF using the sperm and eggs of a married couple, subject to restrictions concerning otherwise prohibited actions during treatment. [10]
There are, however, important differences when treatments involve sperm, eggs or embryos from another person.
A useful approach is to consider the medical treatment and the religious guidance together, rather than assuming that a medically available procedure is automatically religiously permissible.
Is Semen Analysis Permitted in Shia Islam?
Semen analysis is usually one of the first investigations recommended when assessing male infertility.
It measures several characteristics of the semen, including sperm concentration, movement and shape.
The World Health Organization provides internationally recognised laboratory standards for semen testing. [4]
The main religious concern for some Shia Muslim men is not the semen analysis itself, but how the specimen is obtained.
Masturbation and semen collection
Masturbation is generally prohibited under Twelver Shia jurisprudence. However, some religious authorities distinguish between ordinary masturbation and circumstances involving medical necessity.
For example, Ayatollah al-Sistani's published guidance states that masturbation remains prohibited but allows an exception where there is a medical necessity and ejaculation cannot be achieved through lawful means. [8]
His guidance also specifically permits a wife to stimulate her husband with her hands to ejaculation. [8]
These rulings should not be assumed to represent every Shia authority.
Men who wish to follow their religious principles should discuss their concerns before arranging semen collection.
Practical semen collection options
Depending on your circumstances and the instructions of the fertility laboratory, options may include collection following permitted intimate activity between spouses.
A laboratory-approved semen collection condom may allow a sample to be collected during intercourse. Such condoms are specifically designed for fertility testing and must not contain materials that damage sperm.
Ordinary condoms, spermicidal products and unapproved lubricants should not be used because they may interfere with the laboratory result. [4,11]
Some couples may prefer semen collection through permitted stimulation by the wife, where this is consistent with their religious guidance.
It is important to speak with the pathology provider before collection, as not all laboratories accept every method.
For a standard semen analysis, the laboratory will usually request approximately two to seven days without ejaculation, although instructions may differ according to the test and clinical circumstances. [4]
The sample must also be collected, transported and delivered according to laboratory instructions.
Can semen testing be arranged around religious requirements?
Yes. In many situations, it is possible to discuss the collection method before testing and identify an approach that meets both laboratory requirements and the patient's religious preferences.
During a consultation, you can explain any restrictions you wish to observe. Appropriate collection arrangements and laboratory requirements can then be discussed.
The aim is to obtain a reliable result without unnecessarily placing the patient in conflict with their religious beliefs.
Understand semen analysis results using the Semen Analysis Interpreter.
What Happens During a Male Fertility Assessment?
A male fertility assessment is designed to identify possible causes of infertility and determine whether there are treatments that may help.
The initial assessment usually includes a review of your medical and reproductive history, semen analysis and a physical examination, with additional investigations when indicated. [1-3]
Blood tests may be recommended to assess testosterone, follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH), luteinising hormone (LH) and other hormones.
Genetic testing may also be appropriate in men with azoospermia or severely reduced sperm production.
The female partner should generally undergo fertility assessment at the same time, because the circumstances of both partners influence treatment decisions. [1-3]
Privacy, modesty and medical examinations
Some Shia Muslim patients may have concerns about intimate examinations, exposure during medical procedures or treatment by clinicians of the opposite sex.
These preferences can be discussed confidentially.
Where clinically appropriate and practical, examination and treatment arrangements can take account of modesty, privacy, chaperone preferences and the extent of exposure required.
Religious guidance concerning necessary medical examinations and treatment-related touching or exposure differs according to the circumstances and religious authority. [7,10]
You do not need to avoid discussing sensitive medical concerns because of embarrassment or uncertainty.
Use the Male Fertility Assessment Checklist to prepare for your consultation.
Can Male Infertility Be Treated Without IVF?
For some men, an underlying fertility problem may be treated medically or surgically.
This can be particularly relevant for couples who prefer to attempt natural conception before considering assisted reproductive technology.
However, treatment is not always possible, and surgical treatment should only be considered where there is an appropriate medical indication.
1. Treating hormonal problems
Certain hormonal conditions can reduce or prevent sperm production.
In selected men, treatment directed at the underlying hormonal disorder may help restore sperm production.
Importantly, externally administered testosterone can suppress sperm production and may worsen fertility.
Men taking testosterone replacement therapy or anabolic steroids should discuss their fertility plans with a specialist. Prescribed medication should not be stopped without medical advice. [1-3]
Read about fertility after testosterone treatment.
2. Microsurgical varicocele repair
A varicocele is an enlargement of veins surrounding the testicle.
Although many varicoceles do not cause infertility, treatment of a clinically significant varicocele may improve semen parameters and reproductive outcomes in appropriately selected men. [1-3]
Microsurgical varicocele repair aims to treat abnormal veins while preserving important structures supplying the testicle.
Possible risks include infection, bleeding, hydrocele formation, recurrence and injury to nearby structures.
Improvement in sperm quality or pregnancy cannot be guaranteed.
Learn more about varicocele and male fertility.
3. Reconstructive surgery for reproductive tract obstruction
Some men produce sperm normally, but a blockage prevents sperm from reaching the semen.
Depending on the location and cause, microsurgical reconstruction may be an option.
Examples include vasectomy reversal and selected forms of epididymal reconstruction.
In suitable circumstances, reconstruction may allow sperm to return to the ejaculate, potentially allowing attempts at natural conception without IVF.
However, a technically successful operation does not guarantee restoration of fertility or pregnancy.
Learn about microsurgical vasectomy reversal.
4. Treating ejaculatory duct obstruction
A smaller group of men have a blockage within the ejaculatory ducts, which pass through the prostate.
In selected cases, this may be treated endoscopically using a procedure called transurethral resection of the ejaculatory ducts (TURED).
Treatment requires careful diagnosis because not every man with low semen volume or azoospermia has an ejaculatory duct obstruction.
Read about ejaculatory duct obstruction and TURED.
Is IVF Permitted in Shia Islam?
In vitro fertilisation, or IVF, involves fertilising an egg with sperm in a laboratory and transferring an embryo into the uterus.
For married couples using their own sperm and eggs, IVF is permitted in principle under the published rulings of several prominent Twelver Shia authorities, including Ayatollah al-Sistani and Ayatollah Khamenei. [7,9,10]
However, the method of semen collection, egg retrieval, examination, embryo transfer and any involvement of third parties may raise separate religious considerations.
This distinction is important.
A religious authority may permit fertilisation in a laboratory while placing conditions on the way certain stages of treatment are performed.
Couples should therefore consider the entire IVF process rather than asking only whether IVF itself is permissible.
What is ICSI?
Intracytoplasmic sperm injection, or ICSI, is a form of assisted fertilisation in which a single sperm is injected directly into an egg.
ICSI is frequently used when sperm numbers are extremely low or sperm have been retrieved surgically.
Where a married couple's own sperm and eggs are used, the underlying religious considerations are generally similar to those for IVF, although individual procedural requirements still need consideration.
ICSI can assist fertilisation in selected circumstances, but it does not guarantee embryo development, pregnancy or the birth of a child.
Compare male fertility treatment, IVF and ICSI options.
Can Sperm Be Retrieved Surgically Instead of Through Ejaculation?
Some men are unable to provide sperm through ejaculation because of a reproductive tract blockage, ejaculation disorder or severe impairment of sperm production.
In these circumstances, sperm may sometimes be obtained directly from the epididymis or testicle.
Procedures include percutaneous epididymal sperm aspiration (PESA), testicular sperm aspiration (TESA), testicular sperm extraction (TESE) and microsurgical epididymal sperm aspiration (MESA).
These techniques may allow sperm to be obtained without requiring ejaculation.
The appropriate procedure depends on the underlying diagnosis.
From a religious perspective, surgical sperm retrieval may avoid some concerns associated with masturbation. However, surgery does not automatically remove all religious considerations, including those concerning examinations, exposure, anaesthesia and subsequent assisted reproduction.
Surgical retrieval also carries medical risks, including pain, bleeding, infection, tissue injury and the possibility that sperm will not be obtained.
Learn about surgical sperm retrieval techniques.
MicroTESE for Men With No Sperm in the Semen
Microdissection testicular sperm extraction, commonly called MicroTESE, is an operation performed using an operating microscope.
It may be considered for appropriately selected men with non-obstructive azoospermia, where sperm production within the testicles is severely impaired.
The surgeon examines the testicular tissue under magnification to identify areas that may contain sperm.
If suitable sperm are found, they may be used for ICSI or potentially frozen for future treatment, depending on the laboratory assessment.
Australian and international guidelines identify MicroTESE as the preferred surgical sperm retrieval approach for many men with non-obstructive azoospermia. [1-3]
However, MicroTESE is not appropriate for every man with azoospermia.
The likelihood of finding sperm depends on the underlying condition, and no procedure can guarantee sperm retrieval.
Potential risks include discomfort, bleeding, infection, testicular injury and a reduction in testosterone production.
For Shia Muslim couples wishing to use their own reproductive cells, MicroTESE followed by ICSI may be a treatment pathway worth discussing when clinically indicated.
Read the complete MicroTESE guide.
Are Donor Sperm, Donor Eggs and Surrogacy Allowed in Shia Islam?
This is an area where Shia religious opinions differ substantially.
Unlike IVF using a married couple's own sperm and eggs, third-party reproduction raises additional questions about genetic parenthood, lineage, inheritance and family relationships.
Published studies describe greater variation in the rulings of Shia religious authorities than is sometimes assumed. [5,6]
Donor sperm
Some prominent Shia authorities have permitted certain forms of donor sperm treatment subject to religious conditions.
For example, published rulings attributed to Ayatollah Khamenei allow insemination using donor sperm in principle, while requiring avoidance of otherwise prohibited steps and recognising the donor as the genetic father. [10]
By contrast, published rulings from Ayatollah al-Sistani indicate that fertilisation using sperm from a man other than the husband must be avoided. [9]
Therefore, it would be inaccurate to say that donor sperm is either universally permitted or universally prohibited throughout Shia Islam.
Donor eggs
Egg donation may also be treated differently from sperm donation under some Shia religious rulings.
For example, Ayatollah al-Sistani's published guidance permits certain procedures involving an egg from another woman, while raising important questions about maternal relationships and inheritance. [9]
Ayatollah Khamenei's published rulings also address egg donation, identifying the genetic parents as central to lineage considerations. [10]
Couples considering donated eggs should seek individual religious advice before treatment.
Embryo donation and surrogacy
Embryo donation and surrogacy introduce further questions, particularly regarding the relationship between the genetic parents, the woman carrying the pregnancy and the child.
Some Shia religious authorities permit particular arrangements in principle, while imposing conditions or advising caution concerning family relationships and inheritance. [5-7,10]
Religious permission should not be confused with legal permission.
Australian assisted reproductive treatment is also subject to legal, consent, counselling and clinic requirements. These may differ from those in other countries.
Before pursuing donor treatment or surrogacy, couples should obtain appropriate advice from their religious authority, fertility specialist and, where necessary, a suitably qualified legal professional.
What About Frozen Sperm and Embryos?
Sperm freezing may be considered before cancer treatment, certain surgical procedures or other treatments that could affect future fertility.
Embryo freezing is also commonly used during IVF treatment.
Published Shia rulings address the permissibility of creating, storing and transferring embryos. For example, Ayatollah al-Sistani permits IVF using a married couple's own reproductive cells in principle and has published guidance concerning embryos that are not transferred. [7,9]
Ayatollah Khamenei's published rulings also address the preservation and later transfer of embryos. [10]
However, important questions may arise concerning the use of stored sperm or embryos after divorce or the death of a spouse.
Religious guidance and Australian legal requirements may differ.
Patients should discuss consent, storage duration, future use and the circumstances under which stored material may be used before treatment.
What if We Want to Avoid Donor Sperm?
For couples who do not wish to use donor sperm, an important medical question is whether the male partner's own sperm can be obtained.
This may involve investigating and treating a reversible hormonal disorder, identifying a correctable reproductive tract blockage or considering surgical sperm retrieval.
In other circumstances, advanced reproductive microsurgery or MicroTESE may be relevant.
However, some men will have conditions in which these treatments are unlikely to be successful or are not medically appropriate.
Understanding the diagnosis early can help couples make informed decisions and avoid unnecessary procedures.
If treatment using the man's own sperm is not feasible, the fertility team can explain the available options and their limitations without assuming which alternatives the couple wishes to consider.
Can We Request a Male Doctor or Discuss Religious Privacy Requirements?
Yes. Patients are welcome to explain their religious and personal preferences during a medical consultation.
This may include a preference for a male clinician during intimate examinations, limiting unnecessary exposure, discussing who will be present during procedures or understanding whether an alternative method of semen collection is available.
Male infertility assessment and surgery may involve different clinicians, nurses, laboratory scientists and fertility specialists.
It may not always be possible to accommodate every preference, particularly during complex procedures or where clinical safety requires particular personnel.
However, identifying these concerns early allows treatment arrangements to be discussed before decisions are made.
No patient should feel pressured to accept a treatment without understanding its medical purpose, potential risks and available alternatives.
A Practical Fertility Pathway for Shia Muslim Couples
For couples wishing to investigate infertility while following Shia Islamic guidance, the process can begin with a specialist assessment rather than proceeding immediately to IVF.
An initial consultation can review existing semen analyses, medical history and possible reproductive problems.
If semen collection has been difficult because of religious concerns, this can be discussed before repeating the test.
Where an abnormality is identified, further investigation may establish whether the problem involves sperm production, a reproductive tract blockage, hormonal suppression or another condition.
Treatment options can then be considered alongside the couple's reproductive goals and the guidance of their chosen religious authority.
Some couples may prefer a pathway that offers the possibility of natural conception. Others may consider IVF or ICSI using their own sperm and eggs. Still others may wish to explore additional options after receiving religious advice.
There is no single treatment pathway that is right for every couple.
Male Infertility Consultations in Brisbane, Interstate Australia and Overseas
Dr Jack Crozier provides specialist assessment of male infertility and reproductive urological conditions in Brisbane, Australia.
His areas of clinical practice include azoospermia, surgical sperm retrieval, MicroTESE, varicocele assessment and microsurgery, vasectomy reversal and selected reproductive tract reconstruction.
Brisbane and South-East Queensland
Patients can request consultations through the Greenslopes or Springwood private consulting locations.
The consultation focuses on establishing a diagnosis and considering appropriate treatment options, including non-surgical treatment where relevant.
Regional and interstate Australia
For patients travelling from regional Queensland, Sydney, Melbourne, Perth, Adelaide, Canberra, Darwin or other Australian locations, an initial telehealth consultation may be appropriate in selected circumstances.
Existing results can be reviewed and further investigations discussed before travel.
A physical examination may still be necessary before confirming a diagnosis or recommending surgery.
International patients
Patients living outside Australia may also seek an initial assessment for complex male infertility, particularly azoospermia, previous unsuccessful sperm retrieval or reproductive microsurgery.
Where appropriate, existing semen analyses, blood tests, genetic investigations and fertility records may be reviewed before travel.
Any proposed treatment must be considered in the context of clinical suitability, IVF laboratory coordination, travel requirements, cost, recovery and follow-up.
International patient information
International MicroTESE assessment and planning
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Shia Islam prohibit IVF?
Not universally. Several prominent Twelver Shia religious authorities permit IVF using a married couple's own sperm and eggs in principle. However, the steps involved in treatment and any third-party participation may have separate religious requirements. [7,9,10]
Is masturbation permitted for a semen analysis?
This depends on the patient's religious authority and circumstances. Ayatollah al-Sistani's published guidance permits an exception for medical necessity when ejaculation cannot be achieved through lawful means. Patients should seek guidance relevant to their situation. [8]
Can my wife help me provide a semen sample?
Ayatollah al-Sistani's published guidance permits a wife to assist her husband in achieving ejaculation. Whether a sample obtained in this way is suitable for testing depends on the collection method and laboratory requirements. [8]
Can semen be collected during intercourse?
Special laboratory-approved semen collection condoms may be suitable for some patients. The collection method must be arranged with the laboratory in advance to avoid compromising the specimen. [4,11]
Is surgical sperm retrieval an alternative to masturbation?
Surgical sperm retrieval can sometimes obtain sperm directly from the epididymis or testicle without ejaculation. It is only appropriate for certain medical conditions and involves procedural risks. Religious considerations should also be discussed.
Does Shia Islam permit donor sperm?
There is no universal Shia ruling. Published guidance attributed to Ayatollah Khamenei allows certain donor sperm procedures in principle, while Ayatollah al-Sistani's published guidance requires avoidance of fertilisation using another man's sperm. [9,10]
Can I have MicroTESE if I follow Shia Islam?
MicroTESE is a medical procedure that may be appropriate for selected men with non-obstructive azoospermia. Whether the entire treatment pathway meets your religious requirements should be discussed with your religious authority, particularly if IVF and ICSI are planned.
Should we see a fertility specialist before trying IVF?
A male fertility assessment is recommended when male infertility is suspected. Some conditions may be treatable without IVF, while others require specialist reproductive treatment. Both partners should generally be assessed. [1-3]
Seeking Male Fertility Advice While Respecting Your Faith
Male infertility can be a difficult experience, particularly when treatment decisions also involve religious concerns.
Understanding the medical cause of infertility is an important first step.
In selected circumstances, treatment may improve sperm production, restore sperm transport or allow sperm to be retrieved for use in assisted reproduction.
For Shia Muslim patients, planning these investigations and treatments alongside their religious principles may help them make decisions consistent with their beliefs.
A specialist consultation can clarify the medical options, explain the limitations and risks of treatment and identify practical arrangements that may be compatible with the patient's preferences.
Dr Jack Crozier provides male reproductive urology and andrology consultations for patients from Brisbane, interstate Australia and overseas.
Request a male fertility consultation with Dr Jack Crozier.
References
The following references include published scientific research, clinical guidelines, laboratory standards and primary religious guidance. Religious rulings are included for context and are not presented as scientific or medical evidence.
Katz DJ, O'Donnell L, McLachlan RI, Moss TJ, Boothroyd CV, Jayadev V, et al. The first Australian evidence-based guidelines on male infertility. Med J Aust. 2025;223(11):653-663. doi:10.5694/mja2.70080.
Australian clinical guidance supporting structured assessment of male infertility, appropriate investigations and evidence-based treatment. Read publication.European Association of Urology. EAU Guidelines on Sexual and Reproductive Health: Male Infertility. Arnhem: EAU Guidelines Office; 2026.
International recommendations for male infertility diagnosis, medical management, reproductive surgery and assisted reproduction. Read guidelines.American Urological Association, American Society for Reproductive Medicine. Diagnosis and treatment of infertility in men: AUA/ASRM guideline. 2020; amended 2024.
Guidance covering semen analysis, hormonal and genetic testing, varicocele repair, azoospermia and sperm retrieval. Read guideline.World Health Organization. WHO laboratory manual for the examination and processing of human semen. 6th ed. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2021.
International laboratory reference for semen collection, handling and analysis. Read WHO publication.Farid MS. Ethical issues in sperm, egg and embryo donation: Islamic Shia perspectives. HEC Forum. 2024;36(2):167-185. doi:10.1007/s10730-022-09498-4.
Peer-reviewed examination of differences in Shia religious opinions about third-party assisted reproduction. Read publication.Saniei M, Kargar M. Modern assisted reproductive technologies and bioethics in the Islamic context. Theol Sci. 2021;19(2):146-154. doi:10.1080/14746700.2021.1910914.
Discussion of Islamic ethical perspectives on IVF, reproductive technologies, donation and surrogacy. Read publication.Office of His Eminence Al-Sayyid Ali Al-Husseini Al-Sistani. Artificial Insemination: Question and Answer.
Primary religious guidance concerning artificial insemination, surrogacy and related religious conditions. Read official guidance.Office of His Eminence Al-Sayyid Ali Al-Husseini Al-Sistani. Masturbation: Question and Answer.
Primary religious guidance addressing masturbation, lawful assistance between spouses and medical necessity. Read official guidance.Office of His Eminence Al-Sayyid Ali Al-Husseini Al-Sistani. Jurisprudence Made Easy: Dialogue on Miscellaneous Issues-2.
Primary religious guidance concerning semen testing, IVF, donated reproductive cells and other matters. Read official text.Khamenei SA. Practical Laws of Islam. Section: Artificial Insemination and In Vitro Fertilization, questions 1264-1270.
Published religious rulings concerning IVF, donor gametes, surrogacy and family relationships. Read English text.Practice Committees of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine and Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology. Comprehensive guidance for human embryology, andrology, and endocrinology laboratories: management and operations: a committee opinion. Fertil Steril. 2022.
Laboratory guidance including specimen collection, approved collection condoms and specimen handling. Read committee opinion.
Medical and Religious Disclaimer
This article provides general educational information about male infertility, reproductive medicine and selected Shia Islamic religious perspectives. It is not a substitute for individual medical assessment, diagnosis, treatment advice or advice from a qualified religious authority.
The religious information is based on selected published rulings and peer-reviewed literature. Shia Islamic jurisprudence varies between religious authorities, and the rulings discussed may not apply to your circumstances or the marja al-taqlid you follow. Patients should seek individual guidance from their own religious authority before making decisions involving fertility treatment where religious permissibility is important.
All medical and surgical procedures carry risks. Fertility treatments, including varicocele repair, reconstructive surgery, surgical sperm retrieval, MicroTESE, IVF and ICSI, do not guarantee sperm recovery, fertilisation, pregnancy or live birth. Treatment suitability and outcomes depend on individual medical and reproductive factors.
The availability and legality of assisted reproductive procedures may differ between jurisdictions and fertility providers.
Dr Jack Crozier does not provide religious rulings or legal advice. Any proposed medical treatment requires appropriate clinical assessment, discussion of risks and alternatives, and informed consent.
Patients should consult a qualified healthcare professional regarding individual medical concerns. Information was prepared with reference to clinical and religious sources available as of November 2026.

