If you’re trying to conceive and want your fertility care to respect your Catholic faith, a male fertility assessment can help you understand what may be getting in the way. You can ask about semen testing, treatments for an underlying problem and what each option would involve before making a decision. It’s also worth assessing both partners at the same time, even when a semen test has already identified a problem. (1–3)
What does the Catholic Church teach about fertility treatment?
Catholic teaching supports medical care that helps a married couple conceive through intercourse. This can include treating a hormone disorder or repairing a blockage that prevents sperm from reaching the semen. The Church considers procedures such as in vitro fertilisation (IVF) and intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) morally impermissible because fertilisation takes place outside the marital act. This applies even when a couple uses their own eggs and sperm. The Church also raises concerns about how embryos are handled. (2,3)
You can tell your doctor which approaches you’re comfortable considering. If you have a question about how Catholic teaching applies to a specific procedure, ask your clinician to explain exactly what it involves, then discuss it with a priest or a Catholic bioethics adviser if you wish. (2,3)
How to collect a semen sample without masturbation
A semen analysis measures the amount of semen, how many sperm are present, how well they move and what proportion have a typical shape. Catholic guidance describes a way for married couples to collect a sample during intercourse using a non-lubricated, perforated collection sheath. (1,3–5)
Why does the collection sheath have small holes?
The small holes let some semen enter the vagina during intercourse while the sheath retains a portion for testing. In this approach, the holes allow intercourse to remain open to the possibility of conception, in keeping with Catholic teaching. They are there to prevent the sheath from acting as a contraceptive barrier. (3,4)
Arranging collection equipment at your consultation
If you’d like to arrange a semen analysis in keeping with Catholic principles, let Dr Jack Crozier know at your consultation. You can discuss which collection equipment you’ll need, how to obtain it and where to take the sample for testing.
How do I collect and deliver the sample?
Leave 2–7 days between ejaculations. Count from your last ejaculation to the day you collect the sample. Write down the number of days. (5,6)
Plan the drop-off before collecting. Arrange a drop-off time with the service that will analyse the sample. The sample needs to reach the testing site promptly, so allow for travel and parking. (5,6)
Collect during intercourse. Put on the diagnostic collection sheath before intercourse and ejaculate into it. Avoid lubricants, saliva, oils and ordinary condoms. After ejaculation, hold the sheath at its base while withdrawing to avoid spilling the retained sample. (4–6)
Seal and label the sample. Follow the kit’s instructions for packaging. Some kits use the collection sheath itself, placed inside the specimen jar. Record your full name, date of birth, date and exact time of collection. Note that you used a perforated sheath and report any spill or sample loss. The first portion is usually richest in sperm, so knowing whether it was lost helps interpret the result. (5,6)
Deliver it promptly. Aim to arrive within 30 minutes of collection. The World Health Organization recommends arrival within 50 minutes so testing can start within an hour. Keep the sealed container close to your body during transport, ideally between 20°C and 37°C. Avoid refrigeration, direct sun, a hot car or a heat pack. (5,6)
Can a perforated sheath affect the result?
Because the sheath may collect only part of the ejaculate, the reported semen volume and total sperm count may be lower than they would be in a complete sample. Tell your doctor how the sample was collected. If the first portion is lost, the sperm concentration may also be lower than it would be in a complete sample. A very low result or a report of no sperm should be reviewed with your doctor and usually checked with a repeat sample. (1,5,6)
If you already have a result, the Semen Analysis Interpreter explains common terms in the report.
When should we seek a fertility assessment?
For couples having regular unprotected intercourse, assessment generally starts after 12 months if the female partner is under 35, or after 6 months if she is 35 or older. If she is over 40 or either partner has a known fertility concern, ask about assessment sooner. Examples include a previous vasectomy, a semen test showing very few or no sperm, irregular periods or difficulty with intercourse or ejaculation. (1,7)
A male fertility assessment usually starts with a medical and reproductive history, an examination and a semen analysis. An abnormal result is usually checked with a repeat sample. Depending on the findings, your doctor may recommend hormone tests, genetic tests or imaging. If a report says no sperm were found, this is called azoospermia. The next step is to confirm the result and look for a blockage or a problem with sperm production. (1,8)
Read what happens next when no sperm are found on a semen analysis.
Which male infertility treatments may support conception through intercourse?
Varicocele repair
A varicocele is a group of enlarged veins around a testicle. Repair may be considered when the veins can be felt on examination, semen results are abnormal and the couple’s fertility assessment suggests repair is a reasonable option. A Cochrane review found that treatment may improve the chance of pregnancy in selected couples, while its effect on live birth remains uncertain. Your specialist can explain how long it may take to see a change and discuss surgical risks such as fluid collecting around the testicle or the varicocele returning. (1,8,9)
Vasectomy reversal and surgery for a blockage
A microsurgical vasectomy reversal reconnects the tubes that carry sperm. It can allow sperm to return to the semen, making pregnancy through intercourse possible. Pregnancy also depends on factors such as the female partner’s age and fertility. In some men with ejaculatory duct obstruction, surgery through the urethra can open the blocked ducts. Evidence for this procedure comes mainly from small observational studies, and outcomes vary. (1,8,10)
Treating a diagnosed hormone problem
In some men, the brain sends too little of the hormone signal the testicles need to make sperm. Specialist treatment can help start or restore sperm production in this specific condition. If you use prescribed testosterone or anabolic steroids, tell your doctor. These can suppress sperm production. Discuss any medication changes with your treating clinician. (1,8)
What if no treatable cause is found?
Some men have a very low sperm count or no sperm in the semen because the testicles make too few sperm. In those cases, there may be no treatment that restores enough sperm for conception through intercourse. Surgical sperm retrieval collects sperm directly from the testicle or nearby structures for laboratory-assisted reproduction. The specialist can explain what your results mean, whether any further tests could change your options and what each pathway would involve. (1–3,8)
Request a male fertility consultation in Brisbane
Dr Jack Crozier offers male fertility consultations at Greenslopes and Springwood. Bring any previous semen analysis reports, blood tests and relevant operation reports. At the consultation, you can discuss which investigations are appropriate, whether there is a treatable cause and what matters to you when weighing the options.
Brisbane and South East Queensland — Request a male fertility appointment.
Regional and interstate Australia — Ask about an initial telehealth consultation, where clinically appropriate and available.
International patients — Enquire before arranging travel to Brisbane so the practice can advise which records or tests may help with planning.
References
Katz DJ, O’Donnell L, McLachlan RI, Moss TJ, Boothroyd CV, Jayadev V, et al. The first Australian evidence-based guidelines on male infertility. Med J Aust. 2025;223(11):653–63. doi:10.5694/mja2.70080.
Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. Dignitas personae: instruction on certain bioethical questions [Internet]. Vatican City: Holy See; 2008. Sections 12–17. Full text.
Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. Donum vitae: instruction on respect for human life in its origin and on the dignity of procreation [Internet]. Vatican City: Holy See; 1987. Part II. Full text.
United States Conference of Catholic Bishops. Reproductive technology (evaluation and treatment of infertility): guidelines for Catholic couples [Internet]. Washington (DC): USCCB. Guidelines.
World Health Organization. WHO laboratory manual for the examination and processing of human semen. 6th ed. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2021. Section 2.3. Manual.
National Pathology Accreditation Advisory Council. Requirements for semen analysis. 1st ed. Canberra: Australian Government Department of Health; 2017. Section 3. Australian pathology standard.
Practice Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine. Fertility evaluation of infertile women: a committee opinion. Fertil Steril. 2026. doi:10.1016/j.fertnstert.2026.08.686.
European Association of Urology. EAU guidelines on sexual and reproductive health: male infertility [Internet]. Arnhem: EAU Guidelines Office; 2026. Guideline.
Persad E, O’Loughlin CAA, Kaur S, Wagner G, Matyas N, Hassler-Di Fratta MR, et al. Surgical or radiological treatment for varicoceles in subfertile men. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2021;4(4):CD000479. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD000479.pub6.
Mekhaimar A, Goble M, Brunckhorst O, Alnajjar HM, Ralph D, Muneer A, et al. A systematic review of transurethral resection of ejaculatory ducts for the management of ejaculatory duct obstruction. Turk J Urol. 2020;46(5):335–47. doi:10.5152/tud.2020.20228.
Medical disclaimer. This article provides general information. Speak with a qualified health professional about which tests and treatments are appropriate for your situation. For personal guidance on Catholic teaching, speak with a priest or a qualified Catholic bioethics adviser.

